Public Markets— Discussion Paper No. 1
Can operational execution become the next source of alpha in public markets?
Why public markets may be increasingly efficient at pricing information, but not execution.
Can Execution Become the Last Durable Source of Alpha?
For more than half a century, active investment management has competed on one central premise: superior information leads to superior returns.
Investment firms have invested billions of dollars in research, technology, quantitative models, proprietary data, and increasingly, artificial intelligence. The objective has remained remarkably consistent—to identify securities that the market has mispriced.
Yet financial markets have never been more transparent. Corporate disclosures are instantaneous. Financial information is universally available. Research has become increasingly commoditised. As information has become more abundant, sustainable informational advantages have become progressively more difficult to maintain.
Private equity evolved differently.
Rather than relying solely on superior investment selection, the world's leading firms built operating capabilities designed to improve the businesses they owned. Investment expertise remained essential, but execution became a deliberate source of enterprise value creation.
Could the next evolution of public market investing combine both?
THESIS —
Public markets have become increasingly efficient at allocating capital.
They remain less efficient at assessing execution capability.
1. Information has become increasingly commoditised.
Financial statements, earnings calls, analyst reports and market data are now available to every institutional investor. While interpretation still matters, access to information is no longer a meaningful competitive advantage.
2. Enterprise value is created through execution.
Long-term value creation depends on thousands of management decisions: capital allocation, operational excellence, leadership quality, organisational capability, strategic discipline and execution consistency. These variables cannot be observed with the same precision as financial metrics.
3. Private equity institutionalised execution.
The emergence of Operating Partners at firms such as Blackstone and KKR reflects an important recognition: buying good businesses is only part of value creation. Improving those businesses through disciplined execution has become equally important.
If execution creates enterprise value in private equity, why should listed companies be fundamentally different?
A POSSIBILITY —
What if investment capability and execution capability were combined?
INVESTMENT CAPABILITY
Research
Capital allocation
Governance
Stewardship
OPERATING CAPABILITY
Operational diagnosis
Strategy execution
Executive leadership
Enterprise value creation
THE RELATIONSHIP
Investment capability identifies opportunity.
↓
Execution capability increases intrinsic value.
↓
Intrinsic value compounds over time.
↓
Long-term shareholder returns follow.
Markets have become exceptionally sophisticated at identifying where capital should be invested.
The next frontier may be understanding how management teams convert that capital into enterprise value.
THE G7VA EXECUTION GAP
EVERY LISTED COMPANY HAS TWO VALUES—
Market Value
The value currently recognised by investors.
Intrinsic Value
The value that disciplined execution has the potential to create.
The Execution Gap
The difference between current market value and achievable intrinsic value through sustained operational execution.
The size of this gap is determined by four variables.
1. Operational Excellence
Can management consistently improve productivity, margins and return on invested capital?
2. Capital Allocation
Will capital be deployed into the highest-return opportunities over long periods?
3. Leadership Quality
Can leadership attract talent, build culture and execute consistently through changing market conditions?
4. Strategic Execution
Can management adapt faster than competitors while maintaining long-term discipline?
The larger the execution gap, the greater the opportunity for long-term value creation.
WHY THIS MATTERS
For decades, investing has focused on identifying companies with attractive characteristics.
Private equity demonstrated that another question matters just as much.
Can those characteristics be improved?
As information becomes increasingly efficient, investment advantage may depend less on analysing what a business is today and more on understanding what it can become through superior execution.
Execution does not replace investment discipline.
It amplifies it.
The firms that consistently combine investment capability with execution capability may be best positioned to create long-term alpha in increasingly efficient public markets.
Closing —